Cal-Maine Foods: The Egg Cartel You Never Knew You Were Part Of

This article is proudly sponsored by Sew Torn, a film by Diamantis Zavitsanos!

Cal-Maine Foods: The Egg Cartel You Never Knew You Were Part Of

You probably don’t think about the company behind your omelet. But if you’ve eaten an egg in the United States, there’s a pretty good chance you’ve indirectly sent money to Cal-Maine Foods (NASDAQ: CALM) — America’s largest egg producer and distributor.

Cal-Maine doesn’t just sell eggs. It basically is the U.S. egg industry. And its business model is one of the weirdest, most cyclical, and oddly fascinating stories in public markets.

What Cal-Maine Does (Short Version: Eggs. Lots of Eggs.)

Cal-Maine Foods is an egg producer — and we’re not talking a couple of chicken coops out back. We’re talking:

~45 million laying hens across massive facilities
~25% market share of all shell eggs sold in the U.S.
Operations in the Southeast, Southwest, Midwest, and beyond

It supplies eggs to grocery stores, foodservice distributors, and even directly to restaurant chains. If you’ve ever cracked open an egg labeled “Egg-Land’s Best,” “Land O’Lakes,” or “Farmhouse Eggs,” there’s a good chance Cal-Maine was behind it.

How Cal-Maine Makes Money (and It’s Not Complicated)

Here’s the secret sauce:

They produce eggs.
Hens lay eggs. (This is the whole business. Yes, really.)
They sell those eggs at wholesale prices.
The price per dozen is mostly dictated by the Urner Barry Egg Index, which tracks spot egg prices — making Cal-Maine a price taker in most of its markets.
They watch margins swing like a pendulum.
When egg prices go up (thanks to demand spikes, supply shortages, or avian flu outbreaks wiping out competitors’ flocks), Cal-Maine’s profits explode. When prices normalize, so do margins — sometimes brutally.

This is why Cal-Maine is one of the most volatile earnings stories in the consumer staples sector.

The Transaction Model (Eggonomics 101)

Think of Cal-Maine’s business as a mini-commodity market:

Inputs: Corn and soybean meal (feed), labor, packaging, transportation
Outputs: Conventional, cage-free, and specialty eggs
Price: Set by the market, not by Cal-Maine

Example:

Urner Barry price jumps from $1.20/dozen to $3.50/dozen because of an avian flu outbreak.
Cal-Maine’s costs stay mostly fixed (feed might tick up a little).
Gross margin goes from mid-single digits to 40–50% almost overnight.
Net income skyrockets.

In other words: Cal-Maine prints money when egg prices spike. And when they crash? Profits evaporate just as quickly.

Margin Profile: Feast or Famine

Cal-Maine’s margin history is almost comical:

Good years: Operating margins >25%, net income over $600M, fat dividends
Bad years: Operating margins near zero, sometimes negative net income, dividend cut to zero

This is why CALM trades more like a commodity producer (think oil or fertilizer companies) than a boring consumer staples stock like Procter & Gamble. Investors must be willing to stomach volatility — or at least eat a lot of omelets while they wait.

Dividends: The Quirky Payout Rule

Here’s where it gets interesting: Cal-Maine has a variable dividend policy — it pays out one-third of net income each quarter as a dividend.

Boom year? Massive special dividends.
Bust year? No dividend at all.

This makes the stock a strange hybrid of a growth name, a commodity play, and a quasi-MLP. You don’t buy CALM for steady yield — you buy it when egg prices are about to go nuts.

Fun and Weird Facts About Cal-Maine

Ticker Symbol: CALM — appropriate, because investors need zen-like patience between profit cycles.
ESG Darling: The company is aggressively transitioning to cage-free production, thanks to California’s Prop 12 and similar laws.
Weird Moat: It’s hard for new players to break in because egg production requires massive upfront capex and compliance with biosecurity protocols (avian flu is no joke).
Inflation Hedge: Egg prices tend to spike during food inflation shocks, making CALM a quirky portfolio diversifier.
Avian Flu “Beneficiary”: When disease wipes out competitors’ supply, Cal-Maine benefits from higher prices — yes, this is a grim but very real driver of earnings.

Investor Takeaways

Cal-Maine is not your average consumer staples stock. It’s a pure-play egg producer whose fortunes rise and fall with egg prices. Key things investors must watch:

Urner Barry Egg Index: The best leading indicator of revenue and margin swings
Feed costs: Corn and soy prices directly impact cost of goods
Regulations: Cage-free mandates and animal welfare rules drive capex needs
Supply shocks: Avian flu outbreaks can turbocharge earnings
Demand trends: Specialty eggs (cage-free, organic) carry higher margins and are growing share

My Take: Eggs Over Easy, But Not for the Faint of Heart

Cal-Maine is capitalism in its purest, most fragile form: buy chickens, feed chickens, sell eggs. No fancy SaaS margins, no AI story, no metaverse risk disclosures — just a flock of hens and the global corn market deciding whether you get paid.

Bottom line: CALM is an investor’s egg-rollercoaster. Get in when supply is tight and prices are high, collect the monster dividends, then get out before the market gets scrambled.

DISCLAIMER: This analysis of the aforementioned stock security is in no way to be construed, understood, or seen as formal, professional, or any other form of investment advice. We are simply expressing our opinions regarding a publicly traded entity.

MACROHINT

MACROHINT

Cal-Maine Foods: The Egg Cartel You Never Knew You Were Part Of