This article is sponsored by Career Angel.ai!
Why The Mosaic Company (NYSE: MOS) Has One of the Ugliest Business Models in the Commodity World
The Green Giant With a Brown Balance Sheet
Mosaic (NYSE: MOS) is one of the most important fertilizer producers in the world. Its phosphates and potash help feed billions of people by enabling high-yield agriculture from Iowa to India. It’s a critical infrastructure-style business anchored into the global food chain.
But “essential” does not mean “profitable.”
Mosaic’s business model is a wild mix of:
• violent commodity cycles
• extreme capital intensity
• regulatory scrutiny
• unpredictable weather-driven demand
• global geopolitical chaos
• high fixed operating costs
This is a classic case of a company trapped in a business model it can’t escape—because the world needs its products, but the economics refuse to cooperate.
How Mosaic Makes Money
Mosaic operates through three major divisions:
1. Phosphates (Florida & Louisiana)
• Mosaic mines phosphate rock
• Processes it into fertilizers like DAP and MAP
• Sells to global agricultural markets
2. Potash (Saskatchewan, Canada)
• Deep underground mining
• Drilling, extraction, and refining
• Distribution across global agriculture markets
3. Mosaic Fertilizantes (Brazil)
• Distribution network
• Blending and retail operations
• One of the largest fertilizer sellers in Latin America
On paper, this seems diversified and stable.
In practice, Mosaic has zero control over the most important lever: the global selling price per metric ton of fertilizer.
Fertilizer prices are dictated by global supply and demand—not Mosaic’s operational excellence.
Problem #1: Commodity Price Whiplash Controls Everything
Mosaic’s financial performance is tethered to the global price of potash and phosphate.
In 2022:
• potash hit $800+/metric ton
• phosphate prices spiked due to supply chain shocks, war, and export bans
• Mosaic printed billions in profit
By 2024:
• potash collapsed nearly 60%
• phosphate dropped over 40%
• Mosaic’s earnings fell off a cliff
The business swings from feast to famine with no middle ground.
Farmers don’t care about Mosaic’s cost structure. They care about affordability. Global distributors don’t care about Mosaic’s dividend. They care about pricing competitiveness.
Mosaic doesn’t set its revenue. The market does.
Problem #2: Immense Capital Intensity with No Pause Button
Mining, refining, and distributing fertilizer require enormous infrastructure:
• billion-dollar phosphate mines
• underground potash extraction shafts
• slurry pipelines
• processing plants
• railcars
• ocean shipping
• environmental reclamation
• chemical tailing ponds
• drying, blending, and granulation assets
These costs never go away.
Even when fertilizer prices crash, Mosaic must continue spending or production will decline—and costs per ton will rise even faster.
Maintenance capex alone routinely exceeds $1 billion annually.
There are no “efficiency years.”
There is only “spend or fall behind.”
Problem #3: Demand Swings with Farmer Behavior
Farmers only buy fertilizer when:
• crop prices are high
• margins justify nutrient investment
• weather cooperates
• acreage is expanding
When crop prices fall—or when farmers face drought, lower export demand, or tight credit—fertilizer spending disappears.
This is a universal pattern:
• When corn prices are high → fertilizer demand soars
• When corn, wheat, and soy prices fall → farmers skimp on fertilizer
Mosaic doesn’t control crop prices.
And crop prices are volatile.
A 10% drop in crop prices can trigger a 20–30% drop in fertilizer demand, devastating Mosaic’s fixed-cost structure.
Problem #4: Regulation, Environment & Tailings Costs
Mosaic faces some of the heaviest environmental regulations in the industrial sector.
Phosphate mining in Florida and Louisiana requires:
• land reclamation
• water treatment
• toxic tailings pond management
• sinkhole and contamination monitoring
• heavy waste remediation
In 2021, Mosaic had to temporarily shut part of its Florida phosphate operations due to water contamination risks.
Each incident costs tens of millions—or more—in:
• regulatory fines
• cleanup
• lost production
• lawsuits
• future environmental obligations
And every year, environmental expectations get stricter.
Problem #5: Zero Pricing Power in a Global Commodity Market
Mosaic doesn’t get to price based on:
• brand
• customer loyalty
• quality differentiation
• product experience
Fertilizer is a pure commodity.
Mosaic competes directly with:
• Nutrien (Canada)
• OCP (Morocco)
• Belaruskali (Belarus)
• Uralkali (Russia)
• Chinese phosphate exporters
If global supply rises, prices fall—period.
Even if Mosaic becomes more efficient, it cannot raise prices on its own.
Commodity markets equalize everything.
Problem #6: Global Geopolitics Can Make or Break Quarterly Earnings
The fertilizer market is a geopolitical chessboard.
Russia and Belarus control huge chunks of global potash supply.
Morocco, China, and the Middle East control key phosphate reserves.
When Russia invaded Ukraine:
• sanctions disrupted exports
• global potash prices exploded
• Mosaic became extremely profitable
When markets normalized in 2023–2024:
• supply returned
• prices collapsed
• Mosaic’s margins evaporated
This isn’t strategy.
It’s turbulence masquerading as growth.
Real-World Example: The 2024 Downturn
In early 2024:
• Mosaic’s revenue dropped >35% YoY
• EPS collapsed from >$5 to ~$1.80
• operating margins were cut nearly in half
Production stayed similar.
Worker hours stayed similar.
Capex stayed similar.
It was simply a pricing crash.
The business worked just as hard—but earned dramatically less.
The Investor’s Dilemma
Owning Mosaic means betting on:
• fertilizer prices
• crop prices
• global weather cycles
• political stability
• supply disruptions
• global acreage planted
You’re not betting on Mosaic’s strategy.
You’re betting on global agricultural chaos.
If fertilizer prices rise, MOS can double.
If they don’t, MOS can stagnate for years.
This is a macro trade—not a business with compounding fundamentals.
The Core Problem in One Sentence
Mosaic does not control any of the factors that determine its profitability.
Not pricing.
Not supply.
Not demand.
Not regulation.
Not geopolitical shocks.
Not weather.
Not crop cycles.
It controls none of the levers that drive margins.
This makes Mosaic fundamentally uninvestable for long-term compounders—unless an investor wants exposure to a highly cyclical commodity bet.
Final Thought: Mosaic’s Beautiful Trap
The world needs fertilizer. The world needs Mosaic.
But needing something doesn’t make it a great business.
And essential does not equal profitable.
Mosaic is a company that sits on top of the world’s food supply chain—yet sits on one of the most unstable business models in the public markets.
You can make money in Mosaic.
You just can’t make predictable money.
It’s the fertilizer everyone needs…
in a business model almost no investor truly wants.
DISCLAIMER: This analysis of the aforementioned stock security is in no way to be construed, understood, or seen as formal, professional, or any other form of investment advice. We are simply expressing our opinions regarding a publicly traded entity.
© 2025 MacroHint.com. All rights reserved